PeaKeen_logo

Common Mistakes When Ordering Custom Medals (and How to Avoid Them)

Table of Contents

Ordering custom medals may seem straightforward, but in reality, many buyers make small mistakes that lead to big problems. In the high-stakes world of sports events and corporate recognition, a small oversight in the planning phase can manifest as a massive headache at the finish line. Whether it’s recognizing athletes, crowning winners, or celebrating achievements in various competitions, the right medal makes all the difference.

Small errors frequently lead to production delays, unexpected extra costs, and a final product that doesn’t quite match the prestige of the achievement being celebrated. This guide is designed to help you navigate the medals shop landscape and avoid the most common pitfalls. Custom medals are used to celebrate victory and honor athletes in sports competitions, and customers are extremely happy when their unique art and design ideas are realized. Sports medals are awarded for first, second, and third place, as well as participation, ensuring every achievement in competition is recognized.

Introduction to Custom Medals

Custom medals are more than just tokens—they are a powerful way to recognize achievement, honor winners, and create a lasting memory for any occasion. Whether you’re organizing a sports event, celebrating academic excellence, or planning a corporate recognition ceremony, custom medals offer the perfect award to mark the moment. With the ability to fully customize the design, material, and engraving, you can tailor medals to fit different styles, budgets, and events. From classic to contemporary, there’s a style to suit every recipient and occasion, ensuring that each medal stands as a symbol of recognition and honor. Custom medals not only celebrate success but also inspire future achievement, making them a cherished keepsake for years to come.

Types of Custom Medals

When it comes to custom medals, there’s a wide range of styles to choose from, each offering unique features to match your event’s needs. Custom insert medals are a popular, budget-friendly choice—these medals feature a custom-designed insert placed into a pre-made medal frame, making them ideal for large events or when you need many medals quickly. Insert medals allow for vibrant, detailed artwork and are perfect for sports, academic, or corporate occasions. Die-struck medals are crafted by stamping a design into metal, resulting in crisp, intricate details and a classic look that’s perfect for prestigious awards. Cast medals, on the other hand, are made by pouring molten metal into a mold, allowing for more complex shapes and three-dimensional designs. Each type of custom medal can be tailored to your specific style and event, ensuring your awards stand out and make a lasting impression.

Mistake #1: Unclear or Low-Quality Artwork

One of the biggest hurdles for custom medals production is “fuzzy” artwork. Clear art and personalized designs, such as custom logos and unique artwork, are essential for custom medals to ensure your vision is accurately represented. Submitting blurry JPEGs or incomplete sketches forces the factory to guess your intent.

The Result: Redesign delays and inaccurate details on your award medals.

The Fix: Always provide high-resolution vector files (AI, PDF, or SVG). This ensures the mold is engraved with surgical precision, whether you are creating swimming medals or complex military medals.

Mistake #1 Unclear or Low-Quality Artwork

Mistake #2: Not Defining Size and Thickness Clearly

Getting Your Custom Award Medals Dimensions Right

Simply asking for a “standard size” is a recipe for disappointment. A 50mm medal looks very different at 2mm thickness versus 5mm.

  • The Result: An unexpected “flimsy” feel or unclear pricing.

  • The Fix: Specify both diameter and thickness. For high-end sports medals, a thickness of 3mm to 4mm is generally preferred to give that satisfying “heavy” weight.

Mistake #2: Not Defining Size and Thickness Clearly

Mistake #3: Choosing the Wrong Material for Custom Medals

Not all medals are cast equal. Choosing iron when you need the detail of zinc alloy can ruin a custom award.

  • The Result: Rust issues, lack of 3D depth, or a weight that feels “cheap.”

  • The Fix: Understand that zinc alloy is the gold standard for quality custom medals, while brass is reserved for premium military medals and top-tier academic achievements.

Mistake #3 Choosing the Wrong Material for Custom Medals

Mistake #4: Ignoring Plating and Finish Details

Choosing Between Gold, Silver, and Bronze

If you don’t specify the finish, you might receive a shiny gold medal when you wanted a sophisticated “antique” look.

  • The Result: The final product looks vastly different from your expectations.

  • The Fix: Decide early if you want shiny, matte, or antique finishes for your gold, silver, and bronze sets.

Mistake #4 Ignoring Plating and Finish Details

Mistake #5: Too Many Colors or Complex Design

While it’s tempting to include every color of your logo, over-complicating a custom award can lead to “color bleeding” or high reject rates.

  • The Result: Higher medals cost and increased production time.

  • The Fix: Simplify your design. Sometimes, custom insert medals are a better, faster way to include complex logos without the high cost of manual enamel filling.

Mistake #5 Too Many Colors or Complex Design

Mistake #6: Not Confirming All Details Before Production

Avoiding Mold Errors with Custom Insert Medals

Making changes after the mold is produced is the most expensive mistake you can make.

  • The Result: Extra mold costs and severe delays.

  • The Fix: Triple-check the digital proof. At PeaKeen, we make this step effortless. PeaKeen can be your partner when it comes to custom medals, and their sales team are experts in giving you directions in design and placing your custom medals order to ensure the mold is perfect the first time.

Mistake #6 Not Confirming All Details Before Production

Mistake #7: Ordering Too Late

Many buyers forget to factor in both production and shipping time.

  • The Result: Steep rush fees or, worse, no medals at the event.

  • The Fix: Aim to order custom medals 45–60 days before your sports events. If you’re in a pinch, ask about fast shipping options for insert medals.

Mistake #7 Ordering Too Late

Mistake #8: Ignoring MOQ and Pricing Structure

Ordering 45 medals when the price drops significantly at 50 is a common financial oversight. Prices for custom medals are often more transparent than other awards, with no hidden fees and low prices available for bulk orders.

  • The Result: A much higher unit cost.

  • The Fix: Check the bulk tiers. Requesting multiple quotes from suppliers based on identical specifications helps ensure competitive pricing and quality. Many suppliers have a minimum order quantity, often ranging from 25 to 100 units, and smaller orders may incur extra fees. Bulk discounts are commonly available for larger orders of custom medals, providing cost savings as the quantity increases. The average cost for custom insert medals typically ranges under $7.50, depending on the design and quantity ordered. Many custom medal manufacturers offer no minimum order requirements, allowing customers to order as few as one medal or as many as needed without extra charges. To save money, it’s often cheaper to buy a few extra award medals to hit a higher volume discount.

Mistake #8 Ignoring MOQ and Pricing Structure

Mistake #9: Overlooking the Neck Ribbon and Packaging

A beautiful medal looks unfinished without a high-quality neck ribbon.

  • The Result: An unprofessional final presentation.

  • The Fix: Plan your neck ribbon design—choose between standard solid colors or custom-printed sublimation. Also, decide if you need a polybag or a velvet box for corporate recognition.

Mistake #9 Overlooking the Neck Ribbon and Packaging

Mistake #10: Choosing the Wrong Manufacturer

Why Great Customer Service Matters for Medals Made to Last

Selecting a medals shop based solely on the lowest price often leads to thin plating and missed deadlines.

  • The Result: Quality issues and poor communication.

  • The Fix: Look for a manufacturer with a proven track record in many different industries, from swimming medals to military medals.

Mistake #10 Choosing the Wrong Manufacturer

How to Avoid These Mistakes (Quick Checklist for Custom Award Medals)

Before placing your order, follow this checklist:

  • Prepare clear design files

  • Confirm size, thickness, and materials

  • Finalize plating and colors

  • Plan your timeline early

  • Choose a reliable manufacturer

  • Double-check neck ribbon and packaging details

Custom medals are fully customizable and can be designed for various occasions, including sports events, academic achievements, and corporate recognition, with no minimum order requirements in many cases. Many suppliers also provide a frequently asked questions section to help customers understand the fully customizable options available for their medals.

These steps will help you create high-quality custom award medals and avoid unnecessary issues.

Conclusion

Avoiding these common mistakes doesn’t just save money; it saves your reputation as an organizer. Whether you are ordering cheap custom medals for a local school or high-end award medals for a national championship, proper planning is the only way to ensure success.

Working with a reliable expert like PeaKeen helps guide the entire process from start to finish. Their commitment to great customer service ensures that your custom award is handled with care. As a leader in the industry, PeaKeen ensures your custom medals are medals made to inspire and last. They offer a wide range of sports medals, including baseball, soccer, hockey, and volleyball, as well as a variety of trophies for different occasions. Children’s events typically feature smaller and brighter medals, while adult championships often have larger, heavier medals with more intricate designs.

Ready to start your project? Contact PeaKeen** for expert guidance and a free quote for your custom medals today!**

More Posts

Send Us A Message

Contact Us

What customization do you need? – Get expert support now

Haven't Find What You Need?

Contact Us For More

Get Discount

New Client Special Offer

10% Off